- Reid Scott (Vincent Riley)
- Maura Tierney (Jessica Brady)
- Tony Goldwyn (Nicholas Baxter)
- Hugh Dancy (Nolan Price)
- Odelya Halevi (Samantha Maroun)
Episode: Double Down
Air Date: 1997-04-16
Runtime: 47 min
The cops' best hope of finding a kidnapped hired car driver alive is one of the armed robbers who grabbed him after a job, but the immunity deal he demands in return would effectively preclude his prosecution for the shooting death of an off-duty cop, placing McCoy in a difficult position as he seeks to placate the cops, who want the guy prosecuted, and the kidnapped man's wife, who wants every avenue of saving her husband explored.