- David Lain Baker (Self - Judge)
- Doug Marcaida (Self - Judge)
Episode: The Frankenstein Challenge
Air Date: 2023-11-01
Runtime: 42 min
Four smiths must "Frankenstein" together discarded pieces of scrap steel to make their blades; after a horrifying round of testing, the remaining two smiths retreat to their home forges to create the legendary Crusader Bible Falchion.