- Colin Ferguson (Jack Carter)
- Salli Richardson-Whitfield (Allison Blake)
- Joe Morton (Henry Deacon)
- Erica Cerra (Jo Lupo)
- Neil Grayston (Douglas Fargo)
- Niall Matter (Zane Donovan)
Episode: Do You See What I See
Air Date: 2011-12-06
Runtime: 43 min
The quaint town of geniuses is transformed into animated versions of themselves. Sheriff Carter and Allison Blake are secretly planning the perfect holiday surprise for their kids. But a mysterious kaleidoscopic wave of color crashes over Eureka, leaving the entire town and its inhabitants animated.