- Calista Flockhart (Ally McBeal)
- Greg Germann (Richard Fish)
- Jane Krakowski (Elaine Vassal)
- Regina Hall (Corretta Lipp)
- Peter MacNicol (John Cage)
- Vonda Shepard (Vonda Shepard)
- Portia De Rossi (Nelle Porter)
- Josh Hopkins (Raymond Millbury)
Episode: Reasons to Believe
Air Date: 2001-01-08
Runtime: 43 min
The Nicholas Engbloom comes to Cage & Fish looking for John to help him with a murder case. Melanie West suffers with Tourette's syndrome and accidentally ran over her boyfriend. She claims to have done it on purpose, only not to be humiliated as she has been her whole life. John convinces her to tell the truth and they win the case. While handling the West case, Nicholas finds himself involved in a divorce case. His wife wants to end their long time marriage because he won't retire and she feels like she can't compete with his work. After his wife almost dies, Nicholas abandons the practice, this time forever. Meanwhile, Richard teaches Mark how to use a "sex song" in order to please Elaine in bed, and John asks Melanie on a date.